El experimento de la prisión de Stanford

The Stanford prison experiment

The young man put on his uniform without much thought. A beige T-shirt, simple pants, a number on his chest. It was just a game, a university study. But as soon as he looked in the mirror, something in his identity shattered: he ceased to be himself and became Prisoner 8612.

On the other side, another young man was adjusting his reflective sunglasses and trying on a rubber baton. He wasn't a police officer; he'd never had authority over anyone. However, when he put on a blue uniform and was ordered to maintain order, he felt he could do anything.

What none of them knew was that the experiment, designed to last two weeks, would abruptly end after six days. And that their lives and social psychology would never be the same again.

The Stanford prison experiment

The Stanford Prison Experiment was conducted in 1971 by psychologist Philip Zimbardo at Stanford University to study how power dynamics and social roles could influence human behavior.

  • Twenty-four volunteer students were selected, all men, psychologically healthy and with no medical history.
  • They were randomly divided into two groups: guards and prisoners.
  • The basement of the Psychology Department was transformed into a mock prison, complete with cells, bars, and a surveillance area.

The prisoners were arrested in their own homes by the real Palo Alto police and taken hooded to the makeshift prison. There, they were assigned numbers and simple uniforms, losing their personal identity.

The guards, on the other hand, received military uniforms, mirrored sunglasses (to depersonalize their gaze) and rubber batons.

What began as an academic simulation quickly degenerated into abuse.

  • Within 48 hours, the guards began to display authoritarian behavior, humiliating and punishing the prisoners.
  • The prisoners, for their part, entered states of anxiety, depression and submission.
  • One of them (prisoner 8612) suffered an emotional breakdown and had to be released.

Zimbardo himself, who assumed the role of prison warden, became absorbed in the experiment and allowed the abuse to continue.

The study, planned for two weeks, was canceled on the sixth day due to the intervention of Christina Maslach, Zimbardo's psychologist and partner, who, upon seeing the situation, denounced the seriousness of what was happening.

Repercussions and criticisms

The experiment became a classic of social psychology, but also one of the most controversial.

  • Results: demonstrated how ordinary people could become executioners or victims by assuming roles of power or submission.
  • Methodological criticisms: Over time, the scientific validity of the experiment has been questioned. Some argue that the guards acted more as "interpreters" than expected, and that Zimbardo actively influenced their behavior.
  • Ethics: The experiment marked a turning point in the regulation of human studies. The lack of limits and the suffering of the participants sparked an international debate on ethics in psychological research.

Conclusions of the phenomenon

The experiment left several disturbing lessons:

  • Social roles can radically transform behavior. Ordinary people can become aggressors or victims depending on the role assigned to them.
  • Power dehumanizes if it's unchecked. Unchecked authority can quickly lead to abuse.
  • Context weighs more than personality. What we are capable of depends, in large part, on the circumstances in which we are placed.

Final reflection

The Stanford prison experiment is a dark warning: under the right conditions, any of us could become guard or prisoner, oppressor or victim. These are not exceptional monsters, but ordinary people trapped in a context that distorts their humanity.

Today, in a society where power remains concentrated in institutions, governments, and corporations, the lesson remains: the line between civilization and barbarism is thinner than we like to believe.

Perhaps the real prison isn't in the basements of Stanford, but in our ability to relinquish critical judgment when a uniform or an order tells us what to do.

References

Haney, C., Banks, C., & Zimbardo, P. G. (1973). Interpersonal dynamics in a simulated prison . International Journal of Criminology and Penology, 1, 69–97.

Zimbardo, P. (2007). The Lucifer Effect: Understanding How Good People Turn Evil . Random House.

Le Texier, T. (2019). Debunking the Stanford Prison Experiment . American Psychologist, 74(7), 823–839. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000401

Frequently asked questions about the Stanford prison experiment

What was the Stanford prison experiment?

It was a mock prison study that psychologist Philip Zimbardo ran in August 1971 in the basement of Stanford University's psychology building. Twenty-four male college students were randomly assigned to be guards or prisoners, with 18 active and 6 on standby. The goal was to see how roles and settings shape behavior. Planned for two weeks, it ended after six days.

Why was the Stanford prison experiment stopped?

It was stopped on August 20, 1971, the sixth day, because conditions had deteriorated. Guards were humiliating prisoners with punishments, sleep deprivation and forced exercise. Psychologist Christina Maslach, then Zimbardo's girlfriend, visited and objected to what she saw, and Zimbardo ended the study the next morning. By his account, about 50 outsiders had visited before her without raising concerns.

What did the Stanford prison experiment prove?

Zimbardo presented it as proof that ordinary people turn cruel or submissive when placed in institutional roles. That conclusion is now heavily disputed. The study had no control group, its full data were never published in a leading psychology journal, and several of its key moments have been called into question by later research.

What are the main criticisms of the Stanford prison experiment?

French researcher Thibault Le Texier reviewed the archives and reported in American Psychologist in 2019 that guards were coached on how to behave and that Zimbardo's team stepped in to toughen their treatment of prisoners. Zimbardo also acted as both lead researcher and prison superintendent. Many participants later said they were playing the role they thought was expected of them.

Did prisoner 8612 fake his breakdown?

Possibly. Douglas Korpi, prisoner 8612, was released after about 36 hours because of an apparent emotional crisis. In an interview published in 2018, he told journalist Ben Blum that he had faked it so he could leave and study for exams, although he had given different accounts before. One of the experiment's most famous scenes can no longer be treated as solid evidence.

Did the recruitment ad bias the results?

Probably. In 2007, Thomas Carnahan and Sam McFarland ran two ads, one matching the original call for a "psychological study of prison life" and one that left out the word "prison." People who answered the prison ad scored higher on aggressiveness, authoritarianism, Machiavellianism, narcissism and social dominance, and lower on empathy and altruism.

Has the Stanford prison experiment been replicated?

Not directly, for ethical reasons. The closest study is the BBC Prison Study, led by Alexander Haslam and Stephen Reicher and broadcast in 2002. Guards there did not become tyrannical just because of their role, and prisoners eventually organized and challenged authority. Behavior depended largely on group identity and leadership.

What is the legacy of the Stanford prison experiment?

Its legacy cuts both ways. It became one of psychology's best-known stories and shaped debates about prison abuse, including Abu Ghraib in 2004, when Zimbardo testified for the defense of a military guard. Today it is also a case study in how a weak study can harden into received wisdom, which has pushed the field toward stronger ethics and methods. Zimbardo died in October 2024.

Back to blog

1 comment

Personality adopts a role, yet it does not appear eternal; it morphs with its surroundings. Perhaps no one is ever truly genuine.

Sakhessi

Leave a comment