La paradoja del ahorro. ¿Por qué ahorrar mucho puede perjudicar la economía?

The paradox of saving. Why can saving too much harm the economy?

The paradox of saving: When saving for the future ruins the present

Saving is wise. That's what we're told from a young age. That we have to save for a rainy day, that we can't live day to day, that we have to think about the future. And all of that is true... until everyone does it at the same time.

Because then, the result could be that we all end up saving less, since excessive savings can generate an economic crisis, and therefore, make us have less money.

Money is energy, it needs to move for the system to work.

Individual reasoning makes sense… Imagine you watch the news and everything looks bad: the economy is unstable, there are layoffs, inflation is yo-yoing, and so you decide to cut back on spending. Less dining out, no more indulgences, and that summer trip… well, maybe. The logical thing to do: spend less to save more.

The problem comes when you're not the only one who notices. Everyone around you thinks the same, and then no one buys, no one spends, no one invests, and the collective effect is disastrous.

This is where the chain reaction begins when everyone goes into “ant” mode at the same time:

  • Companies sell less
  • By selling less and having more expenses than income, they cut production.
  • As they cut production, they lay off employees.
  • The unemployed spend their savings to survive.
  • The government loses money on unemployment benefits, so it raises taxes to collect more.
  • Working people are becoming poorer, and people with savings are also being attacked by the tax increase.
  • Result: An economic crisis, no one with money, liquidity problems in companies, and difficulty in generating employment and getting back on track.

The master stroke: this collective desire to save more has ended up resulting in less money to save.

What the hell happened here?

What's happened is that one person's spending is another person's income. In other words, if you stop going to the bar, the waiter gets paid less. If no one buys clothes, the store closes. If no one renovates the house, the bricklayer loses his job. And so, like dominoes, the system cools down. And when it cools down, the economy contracts. That's called a recession. And recessions, in case you were wondering, aren't exactly good for savings.

John Maynard Keynes, the British economist with the appearance of a Hogwarts professor who revolutionized economics in the 20th century, already realized this, when the economy was not as complex or advanced as it is today, nor the world as globalized.

In his work, he commented on these aspects and developed his own theory for getting out of economic recessions, of course by getting money moving.

For Keynes, in an economic recession, what's needed isn't more saving, but more spending, or at least, someone spending big. He proposed that the state be the one to make the economic disbursement through public investment, because if no one moves the money, people's incomes decline, and without income, no economy can survive.

So saving is bad? No, don't worry! Saving is good and necessary, but you have to do it right.

Like everything in economics, context matters. In a stable or growing economy, saving means investing: putting your money in the bank, a fund, or a company. That gets the wheels turning. But in the midst of an economic storm, if everyone hunkers down, the ship sinks faster.

There are many ways to save, and the smartest way, both for each individual and for the economy as a whole, is through investments in assets that grow your capital. Leaving your savings static is increasingly less effective; inflation is increasing, as are taxes on savings, so leaving your money sitting still only causes you to have less and less money.

Moral: Saving is good, but if everyone tightens their belts at the same time, there won't even be enough money to buy a pair of pants.

Frequently asked questions about the paradox of thrift

What is the paradox of thrift?

The paradox of thrift is the idea that when everyone tries to save more at the same time, total saving in the economy may not rise and can even fall. One person's spending is another person's income. If households all cut back, businesses sell less, produce less and lay workers off, so incomes drop. With lower incomes, people end up unable to save as much as they planned.

Who came up with the paradox of thrift?

John Maynard Keynes popularized it in The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money (1936), though the idea is older. Bernard Mandeville's The Fable of the Bees (1714) argued that spending, even on luxuries, sustained prosperity. In 1892 John M. Robertson published The Fallacy of Saving, and in the 1920s William Foster and Waddill Catchings made similar arguments. Keynes built it into his theory of aggregate demand.

What is a real-world example of the paradox of thrift?

The Great Recession of 2008-2009 is often cited. As US households cut spending and paid down debt, the personal saving rate climbed, consumer demand fell and unemployment reached 10% in October 2009. Japan in the 1990s is another frequent example, with cautious households, near-zero interest rates and years of weak growth. Economists still debate how much of each slump the urge to save explains.

Is the paradox of thrift a fallacy of composition?

Yes, it is a classic example. A fallacy of composition assumes that what is true for one part must be true for the whole. One family saving more improves its finances because its choice barely affects the economy. When millions of families do the same, their combined behavior shrinks total spending and therefore everyone's income. Standing up at a stadium to see better is the everyday version.

Why do some economists reject the paradox of thrift?

Classical and Austrian economists argue that saved money does not vanish. Banks lend it out, interest rates fall and businesses invest, and investment is spending too. In long-run growth models, higher saving leads to more capital and higher productivity. The paradox holds only if extra saving fails to turn into investment, which is most likely during a recession, when firms are pessimistic and rates are already low.

When does the paradox of thrift matter most?

It matters most when interest rates are stuck near zero, a situation known as a liquidity trap or the zero lower bound. Central banks then cannot cut borrowing costs enough for investment to absorb the extra saving. Paul Krugman and others used this logic to explain Japan's long slump and the weak recovery after 2008. Economies with strong exports feel the effect less.

What happened to saving during the COVID-19 pandemic?

Saving surged, largely because people could not spend. The US personal saving rate topped 30% in April 2020, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis, compared with under 10% before the crisis. Governments and central banks offset the collapse in consumer spending with stimulus checks, expanded unemployment benefits and low interest rates, a response broadly in line with what Keynes prescribed.

Does the paradox of thrift mean saving is bad?

No. Personal saving builds a safety net and funds the investment that drives long-term growth. The paradox describes what can happen when everyone cuts spending at once during a downturn and the extra savings sit idle. That is why many economists support government spending to prop up demand in recessions. For an individual household, saving regularly remains a sound financial habit.

Back to blog

3 comments

Milton fridman es contrario a los keynesianos , considera que no debe haber intervención estatal , ni sobre oferta monetaria , el mercado debe regularse básicamente con la inversión privada .

Raul

Gracias por el artículo, quien diría que desde ese ángulo las cosas tienen mucho sentido. Pues como todo en la vida, todo debe ser a su medida,ni más ni menos,👌. Y lo más importante, hay que VIVIR y disfrutar del tiempo que nos puede sorprender 😜👌. Buen artículo chicos.

Rosa

Gracias por el artículo, quien diría que desde ese ángulo las cosas tienen mucho sentido. Pues como todo en la vida, todo debe ser a su medida,ni más ni menos,👌. Y lo más importante, hay que VIVIR y disfrutar del tiempo que nos puede sorprender 😜👌. Buen artículo chicos.

Rosa

Leave a comment